Thursday, 8 February 2024

Is Infinite Forgiveness Really A Good Thing?

All of us have our little quirks, eccentricities and minor irritabilities, and if we know that the person is well meaning, well intentioned, all of us accommodate, all of us grin these off in the larger interest of friendships, relationships, professional associations.

At the same time, I tend to disagree with the notion of "infinite forgiveness" as being a positive trait to develop. Forgiveness is good, and important, but only to a reasonable extent. Here's my personal balance point on this:

If someone says/does something to hurt/offend me, and subsequently offers a sincere, heartfelt apology, I forgive easily - the first time 🙂. There are times I've made mistakes in my life and I understand that there is merit to realizing one's mistakes, apologizing for the same, and making an effort to correct oneself. If I see all this, forgiveness comes easily to me.

As I said: The first time 🙂. IF the other person has realized his/her mistake, apologizes for it, and makes efforts to correct himself/herself 🙂.

But if this person again says/does something to hurt/offend me, all forgiveness ends. It simply ends.

To forgive or not is a choice we are free to make, there is no moral obligation towards any external authority that we need to feel burdened with. And once I am clear that I'm choosing to not forgive, the very next step I take is to excuse myself from this person's company and create a distance. If I have been offended at my workplace, I'll keep my professional decorum but will no longer interact with this person unless absolutely necessary. If it's a friend who has offended, I make other friends - this time choosing more wisely 🙂, and spend time with them. I will distance myself from this person immediately. If it's a woman I'm in a relationship with, I will immediately break up and walk away.

It is important to realise that "not forgiving" does not mean to "continue in a state of anger or hatred" or to "do something foolish in revenge and get oneself into trouble". No. To choose to not forgive simply means to remove the burden of "being infinitely forgiving" from one's shoulders, step away from whoever has hurt us, ensure that our mind is at peace, and continue to live a happy fulfilling life.

When to forgive, when not, to what extent, these are our choices to make. Just like every other choice in life that's ours to make 🙂.

Stay sensible, stay happy 🙂!

Wednesday, 7 February 2024

The Saga Of Indians Dissing Fellow Indians

The first time I went to an embassy was in 1995 when I was flying out to the US for graduate school. From then, till Summer 2006 when I came back, I consistently had the following experience at American, British and Canadian embassies, as well as on the various international airlines I flew:

The Indian staff disses Indian visa applicants and travellers while sucking up to foreigners, while the American, Canadian and British staff is polite with everyone. Even the Indian embassy at Chicago, which ought to be a place to turn to for Indians there if needed, was rude and off-handish the one time I visited them for a routine passport renewal.

Never understood it! Why should Indians diss their own? I don't think any other nationality in the whole world does this to its own.

PS: To give three examples of the above:

1. An Indian staff member of British Airways at Mumbai once disallowed me from carrying my guitar onboard while allowing foreigners to carry theirs 🙂! I was 21 years old and flying out on a student visa - when I asked her why I couldn't carry my guitar with me, she said it posed a "security risk", in that I might use it to beat someone up 😅! And when I switched to a domestic US carrier in the US, not only was there no problem, the Americans were surprised at my guitar having to come as checked in luggage 😅! This is self inflicted racism 😅!

2. Several years later when I finished my PhD and was to travel to the USA on a different Visa (J-1), another Indian staff member as the US Visa Facilitation Service Center in Mumbai left me utterly bemused with her behavior! Here's what happened: I reach the VFS Center and hand my duly filled out J-1 Visa application form to the lady at the desk. She taps her forefinger on the desk and, gesturing with her hand as she spoke, asked me for my J-1. I, a bit taken aback, said I was there to apply for a J-1 Visa. Impatient, shaking her head, she goes: This is the application form...your J-1, your J-1... It then flashed in my mind that she was asking for the DS-2019 document that University of Michigan had sent me. I of course had it in my hand already and gave it to her. Goodness gracious! The lady didn't even know the name of the document! But she certainly spoke like she lived at the White House!

3. I once made the mistake of flying Air India (then run by the government and by far the worst airline to fly with). As we were getting ready to land the cabin crew handed out immigration cards to everyone, one that was to be filled per person and would get attached to the individual's passport (I-94) and one that was to be filled per family (Customs Declaration). There was a family in the row right ahead of me that was going to the US for the first time. A bit confused after the announcement, the man simply asked an air hostess to tell him once again which color form was to be filled per person and which per family. Just an innocent question! And the air hostess snaps: "Weren't you paying attention to the announcement? The white one per person and the green one per family!" Then she speaks to the atmosphere so that the insult is driven home: "Oh! These so called smart IT people! Can't even understand basic instructions!" To this date I feel anger at that lady! I have never, never ever ever, experienced this level of discourtesy on any other international airline in all my flights outside the country!

Monday, 5 February 2024

A Truthful Life And Innocent Lies

Say a bunch of goons are chasing an innocent person down the street and you save him by hiding him in your house. And say the goons knock on your door and ask if you've seen someone running down the road. What are you going to do? Obviously: lie!

This is an extreme example of a situation when lying is acceptable. Even in softer circumstances, it can happen once in a while that you sense that an innocent lie will result in good for the world. In such situations, speaking that innocent lie is obviously the right thing to do!

When you hear saints exhorting you to live a truthful life, the above exceptions are obvious! The saints know that! They are not stupid 🙂! Neither are you 🙂!

But this is very different from all the lying all around us today! Students cheat in exams, people lie in their interviews, men and women lie to each other to get married, husbands and wives lie to each other in marriage (if a marriage is not working out, it's better to be truthful and end it than stay in it dishonestly), neighbors lie to each other to project themselves in ways that impress, businessmen lie to earn more money, politicians lie to get votes, religious preachers lie to increase their followers, public officers engage in corruption, many lie to get promoted faster!

Why? Why do all this? Dishonesty may seem to bring you some short term rewards, but it wrecks your conscience, it completely takes away your peace of mind! And nothing, absolutely nothing in this world, is even remotely comparable to a clean conscience and a peaceful mind!

Bear one thing in mind firmly: The people who really matter in your life, who really care about you, do not care a hoot about how wealthy you are, or what position you hold, or how many marks you score, or which colleges and universities you attend! They simply want to see you living a truthful life in which you work hard, do your best, and let the chips fall where they may! These are also the people who will stand by you when you go through your lows (which you will, which everyone does)!

Take it from me, live a decent, truthful life, and your external circumstances aside, you will know what it is to have self respect, a clear conscience, and an authentic smile that charms like nothing else! You will work hard through the day, give life your very best, and come night, you will sleep like a baby! These are the true rewards of life, and these simply cannot be yours if you are dishonest!

(And yes 🙂, it is possible to change, that choice is in front of everyone right now, and the right time to change for the better is also right now 🙂 - and this switch is not made slowly and steadily, not in percentages per day, it has to be immediate, just like switching on the lights 🙂!)

Saturday, 3 February 2024

No One Higher Than A Teacher

If you observe carefully, you will see that even soldiers fighting on the frontlines, ready to sacrifice their very lives, deeply respect the officers who trained them and taught them the art of warfare. That right there is the underlying spirit of this post.

If you're good at what you do, no matter what your profession, I request you to spend at least a few hours every week teaching - either on online platforms or in a classroom.

We need the very best in every field - science, medicine, law, liberal arts, warfare - to participate in teaching (either part time alongside their primary practice or as full time academics). If our schools, colleges and universities thrive as centers of learning, as fields where students grow and mature to become knowledgeable, skilled and deeply humane, every other aspect of our national and global life will thrive as a natural consequence.

Bad examples like Dronacharya aside (who refused to teach a brilliant and deserving student, Eklavya, simply because he was not from a royal family), here is a general principle that is important to emphasize in society:

No matter what role you are playing in society, someone, somewhere, taught you, guided you. You have to acknowledge this.

There is no one higher than a teacher in society. No politician, no bureaucrat, no officer, no manager, no scientist, no businessman, no one.

For Knowledge sustains everything and those capable of transmitting Knowledge sustain everyone.

The minute a society forgets this and starts undervaluing its teachers, degradation sets in - in skill as well as values. It will always be so.

(Needless to say, we are only talking about committed and competent teachers and professors But that doesn't change the point being made.)

Note 1: Teaching includes research guidance! Even scientists and researchers have to acknowledge that someone guided them into developing their research acumen at some point in time.

Note 2: At least in this part of the world, the profession of teaching, all the way from teaching children to mature adults (teachers were called acharyas, rishis and gurus), always included a component of contemplation and inquiry. We call this component research in the present times. So at least as far as I am, and this post is, concerned, teaching means teaching + research - all the way from primary schools to universities. If teachers and professors spend some time every day in contemplation and inquiry, students pick up the spirit naturally. And it is important - for everyone - to pick up this spirit.

Friday, 2 February 2024

Setting Mature Exams!

I'm going to keep this post short and come straight to the point:

There are two ways of setting exam papers:

1) Give questions/problems of different levels of difficulty (easy, medium, difficult) and differentiate between students obtaining different grades accordingly.

2) Give difficult problems only, look at how far students are able to progress in solving them, use step-marking to assign a score, and differentiate between students obtaining different grades accordingly.

The second method is more sound because it prepares you for the real world - where everyone gets to face exactly the same challenges, everyone is required to solve difficult problems, and what's important is how far you are able to progress on those difficult problems. Absolutely no one comes to help you pass with easy problems 😊!

Students and teachers/professors both need to have the maturity to stick to difficult exams. Honest feedback on where one stands at any given time is the best strategy to prepare for success in the real world. It's far better to get low grades, even fail once in a while, in college and use the feedback to work harder, than get fluffy grades in college through easy exams and/or grade inflation and then struggle in the real world because you weren't prepared for the difficult stuff.

Note: I believe there are many Indian universities that have been leaning towards the first (not sound) method claiming alignment with Bloom's Taxonomy (further claiming that this is the "universally accepted model" in US universities - which is simply not true).

That's a flawed argument on two counts:

1. Bloom's taxonomy has itself been questioned. Here are two articles to get you started: i) Here's What's Wrong With Bloom's Taxonomy: A Deeper Learning Perspective (Opinion) and ii) Why It May Be Time to Dump Bloom's Taxonomy – TCEA TechNotes Blog.

2) We can certainly learn from different theories of knowledge, learning and teaching paradigms to raise our instruction standards - but when it's time to test our students for the real world, we need to do that without going soft on them to avoid sending underprepared graduates out and disadvantaging them in their careers.

Humility

There are some who are grappling with severe physical/mental disabilities or are going through personal, family or financial situations that are so trying that its a full time job to just survive! This post does not address them! As for everyone else:

Humility, when practiced after having mastered a field of knowledge, or after having refined an art to a high degree of perfection, is meaningful, beautiful.

But short of that, where's the choice to be anything but humble anyway?

Where's the merit in pretentiously showcasing humility as a virtue you possess if you aren't working hard at either mastering a field of knowledge or refining an art to a high degree of perfection?

Are you getting what I'm saying?

PS-1: I'm not talking about worldly success or failure above. There are ample examples of substandard people "getting ahead" in life by being corrupt or compromising on their ethics and character. There are also ample examples of excellent people encountering failure in the world because they refuse to compromise on their integrity. I stand solidly with the second set. Men and women of integrity are men and women in the true sense of these words.

PS-2: No, just being monetarily rich does not qualify as achieving something 😅! That even the Mukesh Ambanis, Gautam Adanis and Lalit Modis of the world can do 😅. Monetary richness is impressive only if you also work on your intelligence and become someone like J.R.D. Tata, G.D. Birla or Sundar Pichai. Otherwise not 😊.

Thursday, 1 February 2024

Make Something Of Yourselves First!

Its funny what globalization and absorbing from other cultures has started meaning to us:

The norm in western academia is that one refers to professors as "Dr. So and So..." or "Prof. So and So..." all the way till one becomes a colleague oneself. This means at least till one completes his/her PhD, and sometimes even while going through one's post-doctoral research fellowship. The reason is simple: While you are still in training, it has to be acknowledged in the way you address those training you. It is only when one earns the title of "Dr." and becomes a faculty member oneself, formalities are dropped and people start addressing each other just with their names.

But just look at the funk Indian students are getting into 😅! Even undergraduates who aren't even ready to earn their own bread yet are starting to have the temerity to address their professors using their first names 😅!

Cut the crap 😅! Make something of yourselves first before considering yourselves to be equals 😅!

PS: Of course, in other matters, such as regularly coming to class, doing one's assignments and projects oneself, doing 20 hours per week of teaching/research assistantship before claiming one's stipend, putting in 40 hour weeks honestly before collecting one's paycheck, in all such matters (which really matter and which is why the west is ahead in absolutely everything by at least a few decades) - well, here we firmly decide to not globalize, not absorb from other cultures, and "stay Indian" 😊!