There was a personal reason to give this movie a watch:
Nitesh Tiwari and myself were hostelmates (H4, IIT Bombay) and I was told that he's drawn on real people from those days. It's good to see him addressing the issue of suicide and making the point that true success is about the effort and not the final result. This holds true throughout life and not just for exams.
But as for everything else in the movie, I'm deeply deeply disappointed! Here's why:
I was at IIT Bombay from 1991-1995 and what has been depicted as the "norm" then is simply not true. There were an ample number of students who did not stay immersed in vulgarity and maintained a good balance between academics and extra curricular activities. They went to classes, studied, tried to do the best they could in academics as well as extra curricular activities, and have gone on to have healthy relationships, marriages, and live good personal and social lives. Many continue to challenge themselves in pursuits that interest them and continue to refine themselves towards higher levels of maturity. (Some have chosen to pursue spirituality full time and that is cool too!)
None of this, absolutely none of this, has even been glanced at in the movie. Instead, what I would call the absolute dregs of behavior and conduct, has been glorified. This is perverse! The same mistake was made by the movie Three Idiots. And movies influence the masses. Student culture in colleges and universities has sharply declined over the last 10-15 years because young, impressionable and raw minds are being given the impression that vulgarity and idiocy is somehow "cool". It isn't! It's simply vulgarity and idiocy!
And where is our censor board? How can a movie that depicts something as vulgar as abusive language involving Mothers as "being cool" be given a green signal? How did we get to this?
And this movie won awards? Is that all we are left with? Rajkumar Hirani and Abhijat Joshi are our Shakespeare and Hemingway and Nitesh Tiwari our Akira Kurosawa?
No comments:
Post a Comment